Consensus and disagreement

The theories of philosopher Jacques Rancière and his politics of aesthetics got a very practical meaning the other day when listening to literature researcher and dramaturge Jan Holmgaard.

He was invited to give a talk at the closing of a mentorprogram run by DIK Association and took his standing-point in Rancière. Very simplified described as two spheres in constant struggle with each other; the current understanding of reality, and the resistance towards this understanding. The gap in between these two is where creativity and modern art finds its role in trying to distort current understanding. A vital society should be one that allows for this gap of disagreement to exist.

Translated to practical work in an organization or, such as in this case, a mentorprogram, it poses some crucial questions. Does a mentorship program institutionalize hierarchy? And is that good or bad? Can anything be done to brake this hierarchy? How would you radicalize the idea of a program for mentorship? What are the blind spots we don’t see, that influence on our understanding of reality and are used as the basis for decisions?

A struggle for consenus, a mutual agreement among a group of people, is undemocratic and just confirms the current. Instead, the democratic line is to allow for dissensus and disagreement, Holmgaard points out. A difficult task, and so beautifully addressed by Norwegian author Karl Ove Knausgård in his summertalk in Swedish radio in August just a few weeks after the horrifying attack by Anders Behring Breivik in Oslo.

We are all pieces in the puzzle of existing understanding and structure in society. This was a good reminder of how important art is to keep us vital.

Leave a Reply

Authors

Lotta Lekvall
Director of Nätverkstan, a Cultural Organisation in Sweden. Nätverkstan provides services …

Cultural and Social Entrepreneurship

On this blog we would like to explore entrepreneurship from a cultural and social point of view. Or rather put forward entrepreneurial initiatives within these two fields.

Search

Share

Archive

  1. april 2015,
  2. mars 2015,
  3. februari 2015,
  4. januari 2015,
  5. december 2014,
  6. november 2014,
  7. oktober 2014,
  8. september 2014,
  9. augusti 2014,
  10. juli 2014,
  11. juni 2014,
  12. maj 2014,
  13. april 2014,
  14. mars 2014,
  15. februari 2014,
  16. januari 2014,
  17. december 2013,
  18. november 2013,
  19. oktober 2013,
  20. september 2013,
  21. augusti 2013,
  22. juli 2013,
  23. juni 2013,
  24. maj 2013,
  25. april 2013,
  26. mars 2013,
  27. februari 2013,
  28. januari 2013,
  29. december 2012,
  30. november 2012,
  31. oktober 2012,
  32. september 2012,
  33. augusti 2012,
  34. juli 2012,
  35. juni 2012,
  36. maj 2012,
  37. april 2012,
  38. mars 2012,
  39. februari 2012,
  40. januari 2012,
  41. december 2011,
  42. november 2011,
  43. oktober 2011,
  44. september 2011,
  45. augusti 2011,
  46. juli 2011,
  47. juni 2011,
  48. maj 2011,
  49. april 2011,
  50. mars 2011,
  51. februari 2011,
  52. januari 2011,
  53. december 2010,
  54. november 2010,
  55. oktober 2010,
  56. september 2010,
  57. augusti 2010,
  58. juli 2010,
  59. juni 2010,
  60. maj 2010,
  61. april 2010,
  62. mars 2010,
  63. februari 2010,
  64. januari 2010,
  65. december 2009,
  66. november 2009,
  67. oktober 2009,
  68. september 2009,
  69. augusti 2009,
  70. juli 2009,
  71. juni 2009,
  72. maj 2009,
  73. april 2009,
  74. mars 2009,
  75. februari 2009,
  76. januari 2009,
  77. december 2008,
  78. november 2008,
  79. oktober 2008,
  80. september 2008,
  81. augusti 2008,
  82. juli 2008,
  83. juni 2008,
  84. maj 2008,
  85. april 2008,

Links

www.natverkstan.net

www.kulturverkstan.net

www.globalverkstan.net

www.nyabalylon.wordpress.com

www.ted.com

www.isk-gbg.org/99our68

www.encatc.org

www.eurozine.com

www.nurope.eu

www.kulturekonomi.se

www.firstdraft.it

http://levapasinkonst.wordpress.com